No single inventor of root beer is known. Philadelphia pharmacist Charles Elmer Hires created Hires Root Beer and helped popularize the drink commercially in the late nineteenth century. Philadelphia newspapers carried advertisements for root beer by 1842, and a New York brewing manual described how it was made in 1858. Both records predate the 1876 Centennial Exhibition, where historical accounts say Hires promoted his own version to the public (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Taplin, n.d.).
Hires made a product that households could buy, recognize, and prepare again. His company then promoted it through advertising and sold it in formats that fit the changing ways Americans bought drinks. The story starts with earlier botanical beverages and ends with a soda that could be made at home, dispensed at a fountain, or sold under a familiar label far from the place it was made.
Root Beer History at a Glance
|
Date or period |
What the record shows |
Why it matters |
|
1796 |
Amelia Simmons published a recipe for spruce beer |
An early American cookbook documents a related botanical beer |
|
1824 |
Mary Randolph published a spruce beer recipe that used sassafras |
The recipe shows how botanical ingredients crossed beverage categories |
|
By 1842 |
Philadelphia newspapers carried advertisements for root beer |
Sellers used the name decades before Hires promoted his version |
|
1858 |
Lewis Feuchtwanger described root beer in a brewing manual |
The drink had a documented method before the Centennial |
|
1869 |
A. W. Chase included a flexible root beer recipe in a practical handbook |
Readers could choose their own combination of botanicals and sweetener |
|
1876 |
Historical accounts place Hires at Philadelphia’s Centennial Exhibition |
The fair helped bring his particular version to a wider audience |
|
Around 1892 |
A Hires advertisement survives in Hagley’s collection |
A dated artifact shows how the company marketed its product |
|
1904 |
A regional history dates the company’s development of root beer syrup to this year |
Syrup suited the growing soda fountain trade |
|
1918 |
A newspaper printed two root beer recipes alongside advice about buying extract |
Household recipes persisted alongside commercial products |
Sources for the timeline include Chase (1869), Feuchtwanger (1858), Hagley Museum and Library (2023), Kelly (2014), Taplin (n.d.), and Tingle (1918).
What People Drank Before Hires Root Beer
Botanical Drinks Were Already Familiar
Early American drink makers used ingredients they could gather, grow, buy, or trade. Roots, bark, herbs, and spices could be steeped or boiled to make a flavored liquid. Sweetening changed the balance, and fermentation could add bubbles. Different drinks used different plants. A spruce beer, a ginger beer, and a root beer might share steps in preparation while having their own names and flavors (Kelly, 2014; Taplin, n.d.).
A useful distinction is between a botanical infusion and a finished fizzy drink. Someone preparing a tea could stop after steeping and straining. Someone making a sweet, lightly fermented drink could start from a similar infusion and add sugar and yeast. A later soda fountain could use a prepared syrup and carbonated water. Each method takes a flavorful base in a different direction. The ingredients used for a tea can help explain the later drink, and the name on the recipe tells you what the author thought they were making.
These beverages also carried different associations in different places. A household could serve a flavored beer with food. An herbalist might present a similar beverage as a tonic. A seller might pitch a chilled bottle to people looking for refreshment. The same broad category could include a drink made for the table and one promoted in medical language. That overlap helps explain why root beer appears in brewing manuals, household guides, and advertisements.
Indigenous Knowledge and Settler Recipes
Historical accounts connect American root beer with earlier botanical drinks in Indigenous and European traditions. Indigenous peoples in North America used local plants such as sassafras in several ways, including for food and other preparations. A U.S. Forest Service publication records Indigenous uses of sassafras, while the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia places both Indigenous and European root beverages in the background of root beer. Those accounts help identify influences without establishing a single moment when the later commercial drink came into being (Chamberlain, 2021; Taplin, n.d.).
The surviving print record is uneven. A nineteenth-century manual gives a date, an author, and a recipe that can be checked. It may preserve practices that had been shared orally for years. It may also omit the people whose knowledge made the ingredients familiar to the writer. Giving credit only to the person with a printed recipe would privilege the survival of the document over the longer history of the practice.
It is equally important to avoid treating many distinct Indigenous cultures as one source with one recipe. The evidence supports specific claims about the uses of certain plants and a broader history of botanical drinks. It leaves the first maker of the beverage now called root beer unidentified. In a story about credit, the most useful language names the tradition or document that the evidence can support.
Spruce Beer Shows the Older Pattern
Amelia Simmons’s American Cookery, published in 1796, included a recipe for spruce beer. The Library of Congress describes the use of hops, molasses, water, and spruce essence. Mary Randolph’s The Virginia Housewife, first published in 1824, also included a spruce beer recipe. The version summarized by the Library of Congress used sassafras root alongside hops, molasses, spruce essence, ginger, and allspice. That overlap makes the recipe valuable for understanding how people combined botanicals before root beer became a packaged soda (Kelly, 2014).
Both writers called the beverage spruce beer. That name should travel with the evidence. The recipes show that American readers already had instructions for sweetened botanical beers, and Randolph’s version shows sassafras in a related drink. A claim about an early recipe specifically called root beer needs a source that uses that name.
The recipes also show how household drinks could fit what was available. A cook could rely on a prepared spruce essence or collect other ingredients. Molasses supplied a strong flavor as well as sweetness. Herbs and spices could change the finish. When later root beer recipes used a different assortment of roots and barks, the underlying idea of a flavored, sweetened brew would have been recognizable to readers familiar with these other drinks.
Root Beer Was Sold Before the Centennial
Philadelphia Advertising by 1842
Theresa Altieri Taplin’s history of root beer in the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia reports that manufacturers advertised root beer in Philadelphia newspapers by 1842. Sellers pitched it in the language of health and promoted supposed benefits. Taplin also describes a market that included businesses selling finished beverages and suppliers selling extract to stores. That evidence places root beer in public commerce decades before Hires’s appearance at the Centennial Exhibition (Taplin, n.d.).
An advertisement answers a narrow but important question. It shows that someone offered a product under that name by the date of publication. It does not necessarily reveal the precise recipe, alcohol content, or number of people who bought it. A seller’s medical claims tell us how the product was promoted. A dated recipe or an actual package can provide a different kind of evidence.
The date matters more than a claim about the first seller. Hires was born in 1851. If root beer was advertised in Philadelphia by 1842, the category was already known in the city before his lifetime. That leaves room for a large contribution from Hires. He could take an existing product category and change how far it reached, how reliably people could prepare it, and how easily they could remember the name on the package.
An 1858 Manual Names the Drink
In 1858, New York chemist Lewis Feuchtwanger published Fermented Liquors, a practical treatise that included a description of root beer. He described a botanical mixture, named examples such as sarsaparilla and licorice, and used sugar and yeast in the preparation. The manual presents root beer as a recognizable kind of beverage. It makes a strong dateable reference because the title page, author, and description can all be inspected in the same source (Feuchtwanger, 1858).
The section is useful even without treating it as a recipe to make today. The ingredients help explain why the flavor family had room for earthy, sweet, and woody notes. The method tells you why an early product could be described as a beer. Yeast fermentation supplies gas and can also produce alcohol. The text gives a historical process and no laboratory measure of the finished alcohol content. Its place in a brewing manual is part of the evidence for how the drink was understood at the time.
Feuchtwanger’s description appeared eighteen years before the Centennial Exhibition. Even if someone disputes the exact date of the first root beer advertisement, the printed manual still provides direct evidence of the name and process before Hires’s widely reported commercial debut. That independent line of evidence matters because it does not depend on a later company origin story.
Chase’s Household Formula Shows Variation
An edition of A. W. Chase’s practical recipe book from 1869 also includes root beer. Its formula brings together several roots and botanicals, with molasses or white sugar as alternatives. It leaves room for changing the blend to suit the maker’s taste. That freedom is evidence of a category people could adapt. A fixed product sold under a single brand would later give customers a different kind of expectation (Chase, 1869).
Compare Chase’s formula with Feuchtwanger’s description and the contrast becomes concrete. Both identify root beer and use a sweetened botanical base with yeast. The plant lists and the form of some flavoring ingredients differ. You can see why a drinker might recognize two early recipes as root beer even if each tasted different. The balance of roots, sweetness, and aroma mattered more than adherence to one formula.
Chase’s handbook addressed readers in several trades as well as households. The drink appears in the kind of book a reader could consult for many practical preparations, including some the author framed in medicinal terms. The medical language belongs to the history of the book. The evidence for the origin question is the presence of a named root beer formula, printed before Hires became associated with the drink.
Who Was Charles Elmer Hires?
Hires was born in 1851 and became a pharmacist in Philadelphia. Local histories describe him working in a drugstore when young and later opening a business of his own. A pharmacist’s background makes sense in the story of a product built from measured botanicals and sold with instructions. Shops dealing in remedies and flavorings were places where a prepared mixture could be made, packaged, and explained to a customer (Lower Merion Historical Society, n.d.; Taplin, n.d.).
Later accounts connect Hires with a root tea he encountered before developing his own version. The widely repeated honeymoon story is one account of that inspiration. The record of what he commercialized is easier to pin down than the details of his first taste. A later retelling can preserve a real memory and still simplify the sequence of experiments, sales, and decisions that produced a successful business. Treat the anecdote as an origin story for Hires’s formula, with the earlier printed recipes as separate evidence about the beverage itself (Armijo, 2016; Taplin, n.d.).
His contribution is easiest to describe in terms of the product a customer could buy. A prepared powder saved people from sourcing and balancing a list of roots on their own. A packet could be priced, stocked, and shipped. A clear name could identify the same preparation when buyers returned for another. Those are specific changes with consequences for how a drink spreads, even though the underlying flavor tradition was already established.
What Happened at the 1876 Centennial Exhibition
Why the Fair Matters
Philadelphia held the Centennial Exhibition in 1876 to mark a hundred years since the Declaration of Independence. The Library of Congress describes it as the first world’s fair held in the United States. It brought together exhibits about manufacturing, agriculture, technology, and the arts. A small beverage product could reach visitors in that setting who would otherwise have had little reason to enter the pharmacist’s shop (Library of Congress, n.d.).
Historical accounts from the Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia and Hagley Museum and Library place Hires and his formula at the exhibition. Taplin reports that Hires offered people a taste and sold packets they could use at home. The combination made the product easy to understand. A visitor could try a finished drink on the spot, then buy the ingredients in a measured form and reproduce it later (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
Think about what a fairgoer could see that a newspaper reader could only imagine. The drink had a particular color, aroma, and sweetness. A sample made those properties tangible. A packet turned the sample into something the visitor could take home. The sale was therefore a second step after tasting. That sequence is more informative about what Hires did than a broad claim that a world’s fair invented a beverage.
What the Date Can Establish
The Centennial is an important date in the familiar account of the Hires product. A commercial presentation tells us when a maker brought a version to a particular audience. A recipe or advertisement from an earlier year tells us something about the existence of the category. These are different kinds of milestones. The 1858 manual and the 1876 account fit together without needing to place the invention of the drink at either one (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
The source for the fair itself should also be used for the question it answers. The Library of Congress guide dates and describes the exhibition. The regional and museum histories connect Hires to it. When you see a sentence claiming more than that, ask which document supports the extra detail. A general fair history might have nothing to say about the exact layout of a vendor’s booth or what happened on its first day. The broader setting and the reported brand milestone are well worth keeping, even when such details are uncertain.
The dates also put the commercial sequence into perspective. Hires’s reputation grew through years of selling and advertising after the exhibition. A moment of public attention can open a market. A product still needs distribution, repeat buyers, and ways to fit into new channels. The evidence that survives from the later decades shows the company working on those problems in different ways.
What Hires Changed About Buying Root Beer
A Packet That Carried the Recipe
A person making root beer from a cookbook had several jobs before the drink could be served. They had to source the botanicals, choose a sweetener, and prepare the base. Ingredients could vary from one shop or harvest to another. A package of prepared powder moved much of that work to the company selling it. A customer still made the drink at home, but the flavoring came from a product they could buy again.
Taplin describes Hires selling packets for 25 cents, with a stated yield of five gallons. That yield was part of the product’s appeal. A small item at the counter represented enough finished drink for more than one serving or one family meal. It also helped shoppers compare the purchase with buying a finished drink by the glass. The historical price belongs to the period in which it was advertised. Its main value here is showing how the product was sold (Taplin, n.d.).
The format mattered for distribution. A packet occupied less space than the gallons it could eventually produce, and the household supplied much of the final liquid. A shop could stock the ingredient package without maintaining a serving counter. A customer could buy it before an occasion and make the drink later. These are ordinary advantages now, but they help explain why selling a small preparation could extend a drink’s reach.
The instructions also gave the company a relationship with the customer after the sale. The buyer could follow a familiar process and expect a recognizable result. Water, sweetener, temperature, and household handling could still make batches differ. The package narrowed one set of variables by supplying a repeatable flavor base. That kind of consistency can be a meaningful innovation even when the original recipe belongs to a longer shared tradition.
Powder and Liquid Extract Were Distinct Formats
The original Hires powder and a later household extract should be described as different products. Hagley’s account identifies powder as the original form. The Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History holds a package cataloged as Hires R-J Root Beer Household Extract. The package gives physical evidence that the company sold a form intended for household preparation. It also illustrates how the same brand could appear in a different format as the market developed (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; National Museum of American History, n.d.-b).
A museum object can answer questions that an anecdote cannot. Its labeling may identify how it was presented, and the object’s size and shape show what a buyer could hold. If the catalog gives little information about the manufacture date, keep that uncertainty when using it in a timeline. The existence of an extract package is good evidence of the format. The first year in which an extract was sold needs a dateable source about that specific launch.
Syrup for a soda fountain is another distinction. An extract sold to households can be intended for a kitchen method with several steps. Syrup for the trade can be designed around mixing a drink quickly from measured components. The word syrup or extract can cover more than one type of product across different periods. When reading an advertisement, check who the expected buyer was and how they were supposed to use it.
A Factory and a Recognizable Name
Hagley locates early Hires powder production at 117–119 Arch Street in Philadelphia. Taplin dates the incorporation of the Charles E. Hires Company to 1890. Taken together, those details help explain the move from a pharmacist’s product to an organized company. A recognizable name could now represent an operation that produced, stocked, and sold the drink across a wider area (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
Scale changes the job of making a drink. A household can adjust a batch if one ingredient is stronger than expected. A company selling the same preparation to many households needs the name to stand for a reasonably consistent experience. Packaging, production, and instructions all contribute. The customer buys the name again because the earlier purchase gave them a useful expectation about how the next one will turn out.
This helps explain why an inventor story can attach to an entrepreneur. A person may encounter a beverage first in the form of a widely distributed product. The package identifies a company and often a founder. Earlier home recipes and local vendors are harder to see at the point of purchase. Over time, the name associated with the first product many people remember can start to stand for the origin of the whole category.
How Advertising Made Hires Root Beer Familiar
What the Surviving Advertisements Show
Hagley preserves an advertisement dated to around 1892, made by the Charles E. Hires Company. The institution notes that the company used a recurring child figure on promotional materials and that advertisements appeared in publications across the country beginning in the 1880s. These are records of marketing activity. They help show how the brand got into public view after the fair (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023).
A printed advertisement can make a beverage recognizable before a person tastes it. A repeating name or image gives a reader something to remember when they enter a shop. The promise of a familiar drink can matter in a place that stocks several local versions. If a family has made its own root beer before, a branded preparation can appeal by offering a flavor they understand in a form they can buy.
The Smithsonian’s Warshaw Collection preserves business ephemera that includes Hires advertising. A collection like this provides examples of what buyers could see outside the shop or kitchen. It also lets readers compare the message across different formats. A trade card, a magazine page, and a package perform different jobs. One attracts attention, another supplies a story, and the last identifies the thing the customer can take home (National Museum of American History, n.d.-c).
Why Temperance Fit the Product
Hires advertised root beer as a temperance drink. The positioning made sense for a product that offered a flavorful, social drink under a name associated with beer. Customers could recognize the idea of sharing a glass while the company presented the product as suitable for households seeking an alternative to alcoholic beverages. The marketing language is evidence of how the company positioned itself in its own period (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
It is useful to keep the advertisement and the manufacturing method separate. A claim about temperance tells you about the product’s place in the culture. The role of yeast, the recipe, and the handling of the finished drink are matters of production. A historical advertisement is not a modern certificate of alcohol content. A company could also shift between preparations for the home and finished products sold through other channels over time.
The same point applies to health claims. Nineteenth-century sellers sometimes promoted root drinks using medicinal language, and Hires’s advertising used familiar ideas about vigor and family health. Those claims help explain the market the company addressed. They are historical evidence of sales messages. The origin story can use them to describe how root beer was presented without borrowing their promises for readers today.
The Founder as Part of the Brand
Taplin describes the company’s use of the story of Charles Hires in its promotions. An origin story can turn a formula and a package into a narrative a customer remembers. The pharmacist, the ingredients, and the fair make a clearer story than a long history of household experimentation. The result is a useful brand identity and a much less complete account of the origins of botanical beer (Taplin, n.d.).
A founder story can still be accurate on the question it answers. The pharmacist did develop and sell his company’s root beer. The issue arises when a reader moves from the origin of the brand to the origin of the beverage without checking the earlier record. The right wording keeps the name attached to the documented achievement. Hires created the brand and became an influential seller of a drink that was already in print and commerce.
Look for the same distinction in other foods. A restaurant may give a familiar dish a memorable name or sell it to a wider audience. A cookbook may preserve a recipe earlier than the restaurant’s opening. A package may be the first version sold nationally. Each is an achievement a historian can describe. Choosing one date for the whole food can erase the others.
How the Soda Fountain Changed the Drink
A Syrup for Service by the Glass
Taplin and Hagley date the development of Hires’s root beer syrup for the fountain trade to 1904. The shift suited a venue that wanted to serve customers quickly. A household preparation was a product people bought before making the drink. A fountain syrup gave a server a base to combine with carbonated water when someone placed an order (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
The change also moved some choices from the household to the counter. A person could order a glass without buying ingredients for a large batch. A fountain could carry several flavors using similar equipment. A shopper who had never prepared root beer could try it while meeting a friend or buying something else. A drink that once depended on a cook’s time became available as part of an ordinary outing.
The Smithsonian Libraries’ account of an early twentieth-century soda fountain trade catalog shows the variety of equipment and dishes available to operators. It is useful context for why a syrup product could fit the period. The equipment and containers were part of the business of selling drinks, ice cream, and desserts. A beverage could gain a place in that setting because it worked with the way the counter was organized (MacClain, 2015).
Bottles and Fountains Solved Different Problems
A bottle gave the producer or bottler a way to sell a finished drink to a customer who would drink it elsewhere. A fountain could serve the same broad flavor at the moment of purchase. A household preparation left final assembly to the consumer. The formats could coexist because they served different occasions. A family might keep an extract in the pantry and still order a finished glass while out.
The Smithsonian’s collection includes a bottling machine for carbonated liquid. It illustrates an equipment problem behind portable fizzy drinks. Once carbon dioxide is dissolved, the beverage has to be transferred and sealed in a way that preserves its carbonation. A fountain can pour a drink for immediate use. A bottling operation has to protect the intended result through storage and distribution (National Museum of American History, n.d.-a).
A precise history of a specific brand’s first bottle calls for stronger evidence than a photograph of one surviving bottle. A period price list, a dated advertisement, a company record, or a bottle with verifiable production details could narrow the window. There is no need to settle that separate question to recognize Hires’s influence on root beer. The dated evidence for advertising, packaging, and the fountain transition already describes several concrete changes.
What a 1918 Recipe Column Reveals About the Old Drink
In July 1918, a reader in Portland, Oregon, asked newspaper columnist Lilian Tingle how to make root beer and ginger beer. The household drank lemonade during the summer and was looking for an option that would use less of the sugar they normally put into that drink. Tingle pointed to molasses as a substitute for that purpose. She also suggested that the reader might buy a prepared dry mixture or liquid extract. For a household interested in making its own blend, she offered two recipes. Her answer shows three ways of making the same kind of drink on the same newspaper page (Tingle, 1918).
The first of Tingle’s formulas called for sassafras, allspice, yellow dock, wintergreen, wild cherry bark, coriander seed, and hops. The second featured a shorter list of botanicals, including sassafras, wintergreen, and sarsaparilla. Both used molasses and yeast. The ingredient lists are evidence that consumers could use the same name for drinks with different flavor profiles. Someone serving the first batch might notice the spice and hop notes. The second blend had fewer competing flavors and gave sarsaparilla a more prominent place (Tingle, 1918).
Tingle’s response also shows how people adapted a beverage to circumstances. Her reader’s practical problem was obtaining or conserving one pantry ingredient. Molasses still supplied sugar, and the column discusses it in the context of conserving the type of sugar used for lemonade. It gives no basis for a modern claim about the nutritional profile of either drink. The relevant detail is that a root beer recipe could accommodate a household’s buying habits and what it already kept in the kitchen (Tingle, 1918).
Why Home Preparation Survived Commercial Success
A brand could sell thousands of packages and still leave room for households to choose their own flavor. When Tingle suggested a purchased mixture, she offered one route to a batch. When she printed two old-fashioned versions, she offered another. A prepared flavor base was useful for someone who wanted fewer individual ingredients to shop for. Someone who wanted a stronger wintergreen note or a particular combination of spices could select a formula closer to that preference (Tingle, 1918).
The recipes also show the work that persisted on the consumer’s side when a person bought a flavoring. The base supplied a mix of flavors. The household might still be responsible for sweetening, dilution, and fermentation, depending on the directions. This distinction explains how a household drink could be simultaneously homemade and commercial. A person could purchase one component while doing enough of the preparation to regard the batch as their own. The distinction is visible in Hires’s package format as well as in Tingle’s advice (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Tingle, 1918).
The date makes the column particularly valuable. Tingle wrote after Hires had become an established business and after the company had entered the fountain market. If the rise of a branded product had displaced the older approach altogether, a newspaper reader would have had little reason to ask for a recipe and a columnist little reason to answer with several. The column records a time when a shopper could recognize a category on a shelf and still expect to make it from scratch at home (Taplin, n.d.; Tingle, 1918).
How a Fermented Household Drink Became a Soft Drink
The word beer describes an important part of the historical technique. Recipes published by Feuchtwanger and Tingle used yeast. In a sweetened liquid, yeast consumes some of the sugars and produces carbon dioxide and alcohol. The results depend on the ingredients and how the fermentation proceeds. A printed recipe that calls for yeast establishes that fermentation was intended. Establishing the alcohol content of an individual historical batch would require additional information about the process and the finished liquid (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Tingle, 1918).
Carbon dioxide can also be dissolved directly into a liquid. Once a business can carbonate water or a finished beverage with equipment, it can separate the job of making bubbles from the job of developing the flavor. A manufacturer can concentrate a root beer base, a fountain operator can mix syrup and carbonated water as needed, and a bottler can put a prepared drink into sealed containers. Each has a different immediate task, but all can sell a drink that a customer recognizes as root beer (MacClain, 2015; National Museum of American History, n.d.-a; Taplin, n.d.).
The transition helps explain why the name endured. Customers had a familiar term for a drink that could taste of roots, herbs, and spices and could be served fizzy. Manufacturers could use that established name as they changed how they produced or served it. By the time a consumer bought a cold fountain glass or opened a ready-to-drink bottle, the process at the counter or in the plant could be quite different from the process in an 1858 recipe. The continuity was in the kind of drink that the name called to mind (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Taplin, n.d.).
A Batch, a Glass, and a Bottle
A packet advertised to make gallons at a time suited a buyer who planned to prepare and share a batch. The price and projected yield gave that customer a way to judge what the package would cost per serving. The buyer also had to set aside time and decide how to store the result. A large yield could be convenient for a household with many people to serve. The same yield could be inconvenient when one person wanted a drink on a hot afternoon (Taplin, n.d.; Tingle, 1918).
A fountain changed the unit of purchase. A customer could order one glass, and the shop could prepare that serving from the ingredients behind the counter. The same equipment could serve a range of flavors. Selling syrup to that shop gave a brand another route to the customer. A person could encounter the name by ordering a finished drink and decide later whether to buy a household product. The move into syrup therefore mattered even while the older packet was familiar (MacClain, 2015; Taplin, n.d.).
A bottle changed where and when a prepared drink could be used. It could leave the shop with the buyer and be opened at another time or place. The person making the purchase could also hand a sealed unit to someone else. Those are routine transactions today, but they help explain the value of carbonated beverage bottling equipment. A successful bottle needed to deliver enough of the fizz and flavor that the producer intended after the time between filling and opening (National Museum of American History, n.d.-a).
Root Beer in the Roadside Era
A 1926 photograph shows a Hires stand at Broad Street and Pattison Avenue in South Philadelphia. The stand had a service window and lacked room for patrons to sit inside. Its design suited a quick purchase. Customers could stop for a beverage, get it at the window, and continue on their way. The photograph is local and specific, which makes it useful for showing how one branded root beer reached people in a new setting (Taplin, n.d.).
The street location also shows the difference between getting a brand into a shop and building a place around the brand. A fountain could carry several drinks, with root beer among them. The Hires name was prominent enough at the stand to tell a passerby what to expect from the stop. A person did not have to recognize the flavor by sight or ask what the business was known for. The name was part of the storefront itself (Taplin, n.d.).
How Prohibition Fits Into the Timeline
The 1926 photo dates from national Prohibition. That overlap helps explain why the years can be associated with soft drinks, but it cannot establish a cause for any one root beer purchase or a reason for opening this particular stand. The federal Prohibition timeline places the start of the national restrictions in 1920 and repeal in 1933. Root beer’s documented newspaper appearances, nineteenth-century published recipes, Centennial promotion, and Hires’s first fountain syrup all came earlier (Federal Judicial Center, n.d.; Feuchtwanger, 1858; Taplin, n.d.).
The earlier dates also put the temperance advertising in context. Hires’s company marketed its product as an alternative to intoxicating drinks decades before national Prohibition. Consumers could be receptive to that message for personal reasons or because it suited a particular occasion. The 1920 law belongs to a later phase of the market, when an established soft drink could be bought in places such as the South Philadelphia stand. The drink’s nineteenth-century history provides the baseline for evaluating the effect of anything that happened later (Federal Judicial Center, n.d.; Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
What Happened to Sassafras in Root Beer?
Sassafras is one of the clearest links between several older preparations. It appears in Randolph’s spruce beer and in published recipes for root beer. The U.S. Forest Service also documents historical use of oil obtained from sassafras roots as a food flavoring. These records refer to different things a cook or manufacturer might have meant by sassafras, including plant material and an extracted oil. The distinction became important when federal food rules addressed safrole (Chamberlain, 2021; Kelly, 2014; Tingle, 1918).
The U.S. regulation on safrole refers to a federal order published in 1960. It treats food containing added safrole or sassafras oil, among other specified substances, as adulterated. It also addresses certain ingredients intended primarily or solely to impart those substances to another food. A separate regulation establishes conditions for the use of a qualifying safrole-free aqueous extract of sassafras root bark as a food additive. The two provisions distinguish between forms of flavoring that a casual reference to the plant might group together (Safrole, 2025; Safrole-Free Extract of Sassafras, 2025).
Why the Flavor Can Survive a Change in Ingredients
The surviving recipes show that the overall profile was already a combination of flavors. In one of Tingle’s examples, wintergreen, allspice, and several other botanicals accompany sassafras. In the other, sarsaparilla has a place. A manufacturer can build a recognizable root beer profile around combinations of spice, sweetness, and mint-like or woody notes. A person tasting a finished soda cannot reliably infer how a particular flavor was sourced or whether a specific extract is present. That requires information about the recipe or the product (Tingle, 1918).
This matters when someone reads a historical recipe and tries to compare it with a glass served today. The old recipe documents a blend and process in use at a particular time. A current ingredient list provides information about a current product. The gap between them may reflect changed food regulations, a change in how a company sources a flavoring, or simply a producer’s choice about how it wants the drink to taste. For a home batch today, a commercially prepared food-grade root beer flavoring or concentrate can be used according to its own package directions (Safrole, 2025; Safrole-Free Extract of Sassafras, 2025).
How a Wisconsin Brewery Made Its Own Root Beer
More than a century after the Centennial, a Wisconsin brewery encountered a different version of the question of how to get a root beer recipe into production. In an interview with Molly Snyder, Randy Sprecher recalled that he already brewed root beer at home when Donna Runge suggested making it a regular offering. He had approached the Runge family about using their ponies for brewery promotion and offered beer in exchange. Donna wanted root beer. The suggestion prompted him to make his existing recipe on a larger scale (Snyder, 2024).
That account gives two people specific roles. Randy developed and brewed the recipe. Donna supplied the reason to make it regularly at the brewery. The account does not require anyone to have invented root beer as a category. It describes a recipe entering the lineup of a business founded in 1985, more than 140 years after root beer appeared in Philadelphia newspaper advertising (Snyder, 2024; Taplin, n.d.).
The comparison with Hires is useful because each man inherited a recognizable name for a type of beverage. Hires used that familiarity to sell a package to households and eventually syrup to soda fountains. Sprecher adapted a drink he made at home for a brewery that was already making beer. The examples show that the same category can have many separate commercial origin stories. Each starts when somebody develops or chooses a particular formula, decides which customers it could serve, and makes it possible to produce the drink in the quantity and format those customers expect (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Snyder, 2024; Taplin, n.d.).
What Rival Extracts Tell Us About the Market
An archival finding aid at the Smithsonian lists root beer extracts under the Allen’s, Carey’s, and Hartshorn’s names. These listings sit alongside Hires material in the Warshaw Collection of Business Americana. The items vary in how precisely they are dated. Together they establish that selling an extract under a recognizable name was a practice shared by several businesses. They also explain why an exact claim about which company first sold a particular format requires evidence beyond the survival of one well-known package (National Museum of American History, n.d.-c).
One 1893 item is a Knapp’s trade card shaped like a hand. The card advertised a temperance drink and gave readers instructions for reading the lines on a palm. The novelty gave a customer a reason to look at the card more than once or show it to someone else. A Hires card in the same collection used a different design, depicting a boy wearing red suspenders and using the reverse to promote the drink. The archived example includes the name of a grocer and drug seller in Farmington, Maine, tying the advertisement to a business outside Philadelphia (National Museum of American History, n.d.-c).
The cards document two layers of the trade. A producer supplied a name and a selling message, and a local retailer gave a customer a place to find the item. A printed imprint can show which shop was associated with a particular card. It cannot count how many customers bought the product there. This is where a museum record adds detail to the broad claim that root beer grew in popularity. It shows one of the ways a buyer in another town could learn about the drink and connect a national brand with a nearby counter (National Museum of American History, n.d.-c).
How to Read Claims About the First Root Beer
A statement about the first root beer should identify the event being dated. An advertisement can establish that someone was promoting a drink by a given year. A recipe can show how one author advised readers to make it. An exhibition account can document promotion to visitors. A company incorporation date can establish when a business acquired a particular legal form. Putting those dates into the same timeline is useful precisely because they answer different questions (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
What a Dated Advertisement Proves
The date of a newspaper issue sets a point by which a drink was available or at least advertised. It cannot by itself show when the seller first offered it. It also leaves open the possibility that another seller served a similar drink without placing an advertisement that survives. The Philadelphia listings are strong evidence against claims that the beverage was invented decades later. They are a starting point for tracing the name and its trade in the city (Taplin, n.d.).
Advertisements can establish how a seller wanted consumers to understand a product. Hires’s printed promotions tell us about the value the business put on yield, flavor, and temperance. Claims on packaging about health or vigor show the marketing language of the period. Separate evidence would be needed to establish the effect on consumers or verify a medical claim. An advertisement is especially informative when the question is how the producer intended to reach the public (Hagley Museum and Library, 2023).
What a Dated Recipe Proves
Feuchtwanger’s manual documents a drink by name and supplies evidence about its production. A reader can check the heading, ingredients, and process against the published edition. The formula can be compared with what Chase printed and what Tingle published later. The comparison shows which choices reappear and which vary, such as the selection of botanicals or the use of a prepared flavor mixture (Chase, 1869; Feuchtwanger, 1858; Tingle, 1918).
The value of the recipe is in what the author thought readers could make at that time. It does not identify who first combined those ingredients or how many people actually followed the formula. Even an author who calls a preparation old-fashioned provides only a relative description unless the account identifies another dated source. Tingle’s use of the term is useful evidence that she regarded the methods as established in 1918 (Tingle, 1918).
What a Later Recollection Adds
A recollection can describe conversations and motivations that rarely appear on a label or in a price list. The story of Donna Runge gives a reason why a brewery founder expanded his home recipe into a regular product. The story of Hires encountering an earlier preparation gives readers a possible account of what sparked his interest. The accounts have different provenance. Snyder reported conversations with the people involved, while the nineteenth-century Hires story comes through later historical retellings (Armijo, 2016; Snyder, 2024; Taplin, n.d.).
A specific detail can be valuable without answering every other question. A memory of discussing a recipe tells us what the people involved remembered. A surviving carton shows what a company asked customers to buy. A published formula tells us what one writer taught readers to do. Used together, the records give a fuller picture of how an idea moved from kitchen to business and how the branded product became part of a larger market (National Museum of American History, n.d.-b; Snyder, 2024; Taplin, n.d.).
Frequently Asked Questions About Who Invented Root Beer
Did Charles Hires Invent Root Beer?
Charles Elmer Hires developed, marketed, and popularized Hires Root Beer. His company took a drink with an established name and made its own version recognizable through promotion and packaging. Newspaper advertising and brewing instructions establish that root beer existed before he introduced his product at the Centennial Exhibition. His accomplishment is best described as developing and commercializing a branded version (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
Was Root Beer Invented in Philadelphia?
Philadelphia is where the surviving record used here puts early advertised root beer sales and Hires’s major promotional work. The city is therefore central to the history of the trade. A known newspaper listing gives a place and a date for an offer to sell. It leaves open when and where the earliest home preparation happened (Taplin, n.d.).
Did Indigenous Peoples Invent Root Beer?
Indigenous peoples in North America used plants later associated with root beer, including sassafras. That knowledge belongs in the history of the ingredients. The nineteenth-century drink also reflects brewing and kitchen practices that can be traced through printed recipes. The sources document several contributions and give no basis for identifying one Indigenous nation or one person as the inventor of the finished drink (Chamberlain, 2021; Feuchtwanger, 1858; Kelly, 2014).
What Was the Original Root Beer Recipe?
There is no verified single original formula. Early recipes vary. A reader looking for a specific historical recipe should identify its author and date, such as the formula in Feuchtwanger’s 1858 brewing manual. Someone looking for the flavor of Hires’s first product is asking about a proprietary commercial blend, a different question from how households or brewers prepared root beer at the time (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Tingle, 1918).
Was It First Called Root Tea?
Root tea appears in accounts of how Hires developed or named his product. The phrase can help explain the relationship between hot or steeped botanical preparations and what he chose to market. A name used in the story of one business cannot establish the original name of the beverage category. The earlier dated records already use the words root beer (Armijo, 2016; Feuchtwanger, 1858; Taplin, n.d.).
Why Does a Soda Have Beer in Its Name?
Historical recipes used brewing methods, including fermentation with yeast. Some sellers later made the fizz available by mixing syrup and carbonated water or by packaging a finished carbonated drink. The word remained familiar across these production methods. Today, a person who sees a product marked hard root beer should read the alcohol information for that product. The historical name alone gives no alcohol measurement for a recipe or serving (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Taplin, n.d.; Tingle, 1918).
What Happened at the 1876 Centennial Exhibition?
Hires promoted his branded preparation at the Philadelphia fair. The event was an opportunity to demonstrate the product and give visitors a way to buy a preparation they could use at home. It marks an important moment in the business history of Hires Root Beer, while the 1842 Philadelphia ads and the 1858 brewing manual document an earlier history for the drink (Feuchtwanger, 1858; Library of Congress, n.d.; Taplin, n.d.).
Who Deserves the Credit?
The people whose names are attached to root beer belong to different points in its history. Indigenous communities held and used knowledge of local plants. Recipe writers documented ways of brewing with botanicals and sweeteners. Early sellers made root beer available in places such as Philadelphia. Hires made his own version a branded product and gave customers several ways to buy it. By the time a patron could stop at a Hires stand in South Philadelphia, the name had traveled through recipes, newspaper advertisements, a world’s fair, household packages, and fountain service. The evidence identifies Charles Elmer Hires as the businessman who popularized Hires Root Beer. The identity of the person who first made root beer remains unknown (Chamberlain, 2021; Feuchtwanger, 1858; Hagley Museum and Library, 2023; Taplin, n.d.).
References
Armijo, S. (2016, November 17). Hires root beer. History of the Soda Fountain, Scalar https://scalar.usc.edu/works/history-of-the-soda-fountain/hires-root-beer
Chamberlain, J. (2021, June). NTFPs from trees: Sassafras (Science Update SRS-145). U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station. https://doi.org/10.2737/SRS-SU-145
Chase, A. W. (1869). Dr. Chase’s recipes, or, Information for everybody (2nd Canadian ed.). E. A. Taylor. https://0x0.la/survivorlibrary/library-formulas/chases_recipes-1869.pdf
Federal Judicial Center. (n.d.). Prohibition in the federal courts: A timeline. https://www.fjc.gov/history/exhibits/prohibition-in-federal-courts-timeline
Feuchtwanger, L. (1858). Fermented liquors: A treatise on brewing, distilling, rectifying, and manufacturing of sugars, wines, spirits, and all known liquors, including cider and vinegar. https://www.survivorlibrary.com/library/fermented_liquors-a_treatise_on_brewing_1858.pdf
Hagley Museum and Library. (2023, February 8). This ca. 1892 advertisement for Hires root beer was produced by the Charles E. Hires Company ... https://www.hagley.org/research/news/hagley-vault/ca-1892-advertisement-hires-root-beer-was-produced-charles-e-hires
Kelly, A. (2014, September 29). Early American beer. Inside Adams, Library of Congress. https://blogs.loc.gov/inside_adams/2014/09/early-american-beer/
Library of Congress. (n.d.). Philadelphia’s World Fair: Topics in Chronicling America. https://guides.loc.gov/chronicling-america-worlds-fair-philadelphia
Lower Merion Historical Society. (n.d.). Charles E. Hires’ Rose Hill. https://collections.lowermerionhistory.org/home/full-text/contents/rose-hill/
MacClain, A. (2015, June 8). Cool off with soda fountains from the past. Unbound, Smithsonian Libraries. https://blog.library.si.edu/blog/2015/06/08/cool-off-with-soda-fountains-from-the-past/
National Museum of American History. (n.d.-a). Carbonated liquid bottling machine [Museum object]. Smithsonian Institution. https://collections.si.edu/search/detail/edanmdm%3Anmah_2625?print=yes
National Museum of American History. (n.d.-b). Hires R-J root beer household extract [Museum object]. Smithsonian Institution. https://www.americanhistory.si.edu/collections/object/nmah_737734
National Museum of American History. (n.d.-c). Warshaw collection of business Americana subject categories: Beverages [Archival finding aid]. Smithsonian Institution. https://sirismm.si.edu/EADpdfs/NMAH.AC.0060.S01.01.Beverages.pdf
Safrole, 21 C.F.R. § 189.180 (2025). https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/21/189.180
Safrole-free extract of sassafras, 21 C.F.R. § 172.580 (2025). https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/21/172.580
Snyder, M. (2024, June 17). Meet the woman who inspired Randy Sprecher to make root beer. OnMilwaukee. https://onmilwaukee.com/articles/donna-runge-sprecher-root-beer
Taplin, T. A. (n.d.). Root beer. The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia. https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/essays/root-beer/
Tingle, L. (1918, July 28). [Column on making root beer and ginger beer]. The Sunday Oregonian, sec. 5, p. 6. https://oregonnews.uoregon.edu/lccn/sn83045782/1918-07-28/ed-1/seq-64.pdf