Slide image

Shop our new arrivals:



Shipped directly from our brewery in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Cart 0

Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

The History of Cola

The History of Cola

Cola began as a meeting of ingredients, technologies, and commercial ideas from several parts of the world. West African kola nuts supplied a stimulant and eventually a name. South American coca leaves attracted nineteenth-century pharmacists. Carbonated water gave syrup-based drinks their fizz. American drugstores brought these elements into a business that would grow far beyond the soda fountain.

The familiar story often starts in Atlanta in 1886, when John Pemberton introduced Coca-Cola. That date is essential to the history of one influential brand, but cola has a broader history. Its development also includes African trade and hospitality, the movement of plants across the Atlantic, competing pharmacy recipes, local bottlers, packaging inventions, changing sweeteners, and consumers who developed strong loyalties to particular drinks.

Understanding those connections explains how cola became both an everyday refreshment and a product with cultural meaning far beyond its ingredients.

What Is Cola?

Cola is a category of flavored carbonated soft drink. Coca-Cola, Pepsi, Royal Crown, and craft colas are individual products within that category. Their recipes differ, even when consumers recognize them as belonging to the same family.

The word comes from kola, the caffeine-containing nut associated with the drink’s early development. Over time, however, cola became a flavor identity as well as an ingredient reference. The name on a modern bottle does not establish that it contains kola extract, coca extract, caffeine, or any particular sweetener. Those details depend on the product.

This distinction matters when tracing origins. The traditional use of kola nuts, the invention of carbonated water, and the creation of a branded cola syrup are separate developments. They occurred in different places and periods before becoming connected through commerce.

Cola’s history therefore has several beginnings: a botanical beginning in Africa, a technical beginning in experiments with gases, and a commercial beginning in the pharmacy and bottling industries. No single inventor created all three.

Kola Nuts Before Cola Soda

A West African Ingredient With a Long History

Kola nuts had established cultural and economic importance long before anyone sold a cola soft drink. Wellcome Collection’s exhibition on kola traces their role in West African culture and trade to at least the eleventh century. Their caffeine content made them valued stimulants, while their social uses included ceremonies and expressions of goodwill (Wellcome Collection, n.d.).

The nut’s significance extended beyond the physical act of eating it. Offering and sharing kola could recognize a relationship, welcome a visitor, or mark an important occasion. These practices differed among communities. They should not be reduced to a single tradition shared identically across an entire region.

Wellcome’s discussion of Igbo hospitality, for example, describes a ceremonial sequence in which kola is offered, blessed, broken, and shared. A surviving carved kola bowl provides material evidence of the care given to that practice (Wellcome Collection, n.d.).

This background changes the usual perspective on cola. The nut was not an obscure plant waiting for an American manufacturer to discover a use for it. It already belonged to systems of cultivation, exchange, knowledge, and social meaning.

A Stimulant With Ceremonial Meaning

Historian Lalita Kaplish describes kola’s place at weddings, naming ceremonies, funerals, and the completion of business agreements. Its bitter taste did not prevent people from valuing it. Its effects and the relationships expressed through sharing it were part of its importance (Kaplish, 2025).

Those uses also explain why kola cannot be understood only as an early soda ingredient. A manufactured drink selects particular properties from a plant, such as its flavor or caffeine. A ceremonial exchange can involve obligations, respect, identity, and hospitality that do not transfer into the finished beverage.

The eventual commercial success of cola made the name internationally familiar. It did not make the earlier African meanings disappear. Kola continued to have a life outside the soft drink industry, even as many people encountered the word mainly through bottles, advertisements, and restaurant menus.

How Kola Crossed the Atlantic

The movement of kola into the Americas was connected to the forced movement of African people and to the preservation of African knowledge. Research presented by historian Shantelle George at UCLA examines how kola became part of religious, medicinal, and cultural life in the Caribbean (Sprague, 2017).

That movement was more complex than a straightforward export story. People carried knowledge about how to use the nut, what it meant, and how it belonged in social or religious practice. The plant’s presence in a new place could support connections to a homeland from which people had been violently separated.

European observers recorded kola’s uses through their own commercial and medical interests. Their accounts preserve information, but they do not represent the whole history of the people who cultivated and used it. George’s work places African and Caribbean experiences back into a story often told through European botanical collecting or American product invention (Sprague, 2017).

By the nineteenth century, European and American manufacturers were increasingly interested in extracting useful substances from plants. Kola entered that world as a possible source of stimulation and a marketable ingredient. The transition from shared nut to standardized extract helped make later commercial beverages possible (Kaplish, 2025).

Carbonated Water Made Cola Possible

The Search for Artificial Mineral Water

Cola also depended on an invention with a separate history: the ability to dissolve carbon dioxide in water.

During his time in Leeds between 1767 and 1773, Joseph Priestley experimented with carbon dioxide from a local brewery. The University of Leeds describes how he captured the gas and used it to produce soda water (University of Leeds, n.d.).

This connected the study of gases with a practical beverage. Naturally sparkling waters already existed. Artificial carbonation created a way to reproduce an important part of that experience without depending on a particular spring.

Priestley’s experiments did not produce cola. They helped establish the technological foundation on which a much larger family of carbonated drinks could develop. Flavorings, sweeteners, equipment, and commercial distribution would be added through later work.

Why Carbonation Changed the Business

A syrup can be sold as an ingredient. Mixed with carbonated water, it becomes a drink prepared for immediate consumption. That separation between concentrated flavor and finished beverage would become central to the cola business.

It allowed a manufacturer to make a concentrated product in one place while a retailer added water near the customer. Later, bottlers would perform that final production step on a much larger scale.

Carbonation also created a packaging problem. A finished drink needed a container and closure that could retain pressure. A recipe alone could not solve that problem. Cola’s expansion would depend on production equipment and packaging as much as on flavor.

Why Early Cola Was Sold in Pharmacies

Nineteenth-century pharmacies sold more than prescriptions. They were places where consumers encountered prepared remedies, plant extracts, tonic wines, and eventually flavored carbonated drinks.

The National Library of Medicine’s exhibition on cocaine documents the period’s interest in coca preparations and the medical claims attached to them. Cocaine was isolated from coca leaves in 1860. During the following decades, coca products appeared in a market that mixed legitimate medical applications with expansive promotional promises (National Library of Medicine, n.d.).

For a pharmacist developing a beverage, this environment offered ingredients, equipment, customers, and a language of supposed benefit. Terms such as tonic or restorative could help position a new product even when the claims would not meet modern standards of evidence.

The pharmacy setting also supplied an established way to serve the drink. A customer could order a glass at the fountain, and an employee could combine syrup with carbonated water. The manufacturer did not initially need a national network of finished bottled beverages.

Early cola consequently belonged to two overlapping businesses: refreshment and the promotion of health-related preparations. Its later success would increasingly depend on the first.

Coca and Kola Were Different Ingredients

The similarity between the words coca and cola can obscure an important distinction. Coca and kola are different plants with different geographical histories.

Coca leaves came from South America. Kola nuts came from West Africa. Cocaine is an alkaloid obtained from coca leaves; the kola nut’s stimulant association centers on caffeine. Treating the two names as interchangeable creates confusion about both the original beverage and modern colas (National Library of Medicine, n.d.; Wellcome Collection, n.d.).

The early Coca-Cola name referred to ingredients associated with the recipe’s development. It does not follow that every drink later called cola used the same combination.

This is one reason a history of cola needs to distinguish a category from its most famous trademark. As competing products developed, cola became a recognizable commercial type. Manufacturers could compete within that type while making different choices about extracts, flavorings, caffeine, and sweeteners.

1886: Coca-Cola Arrives in Atlanta

John Pemberton’s Earlier Tonic

John Pemberton developed Coca-Cola after working on an alcoholic product called Pemberton’s French Wine Coca. Introduced in 1885, that earlier drink was promoted as a nerve tonic and a remedy for headaches. It drew inspiration from the coca wine Vin Mariani (Library of Congress, n.d.-b).

A local prohibition measure created a reason to develop a nonalcoholic alternative. This was part of Atlanta-area history in the 1880s. It occurred decades before national Prohibition began in the United States in 1920.

The distinction matters because the familiar shorthand that Coca-Cola was invented during Prohibition can lead readers to place the event in the wrong period. Pemberton was responding to a local commercial situation, not to the later nationwide ban.

The First Serving at Jacobs’ Pharmacy

The Library of Congress identifies May 8, 1886, as the date the first Coca-Cola was served at Jacobs’ Pharmacy in Atlanta. The product was sold as syrup mixed with carbonated water at the place of service. Pemberton died in 1888, before the drink achieved its later scale (Library of Congress, n.d.-b).

That first sale was the beginning of a particular branded beverage, rather than the invention of soda itself. Carbonated water, flavored fountain drinks, and plant-based tonics already existed. Pemberton’s contribution was a formulation and product that could compete in that established market.

Did Early Coca-Cola Contain Cocaine?

Early Coca-Cola contained coca-leaf extract that included cocaine. The Library of Congress identifies that extract, together with caffeine-rich kola nut, among the drink’s original ingredients (Library of Congress, n.d.-a).

The formula changed as the product developed. The New Georgia Encyclopedia places the removal of cocaine before the 1906 Pure Food and Drugs Act. It is therefore inaccurate to treat today’s beverage as an unchanged version of the nineteenth-century tonic (Giebelhaus, 2017).

This part of the story also requires precise language. A coca leaf, an extract made from it, and purified cocaine are related but distinct materials. The historical presence of cocaine in a coca preparation does not establish the dose in every serving or the composition of every later formulation. Exact quantities require evidence for a specific recipe and date.

Naming and Branding Turned a Recipe Into a Product

Pemberton’s associate Frank M. Robinson coined the Coca-Cola name and developed its famous script identity. Asa Griggs Candler subsequently acquired control of the business and expanded the manufacture and distribution of its syrup (Giebelhaus, 2017).

A repeatable recipe and a recognizable name served different functions. The recipe gave the drink a taste. The name allowed a customer to request that taste again and helped a seller distinguish it from nearby alternatives.

This distinction became more valuable as the product moved beyond a single pharmacy. A consumer in another town needed a reason to connect a new glass of soda with a previous experience. Consistent branding supplied that connection.

The brand also gave advertising a specific object. An advertisement could ask people to buy Coca-Cola rather than simply to visit a fountain for something refreshing. That changed the commercial relationship among manufacturer, retailer, and customer.

The manufacturer was building demand for a named product that many independent businesses could sell. Later bottling arrangements would make that approach even more powerful.

Bottling Took Cola Beyond the Soda Fountain

Concentrate, Local Production, and Distribution

An important Coca-Cola bottling agreement in 1899 gave Benjamin Franklin Thomas and Joseph Brown Whitehead a foundation for expanding bottled distribution. Earlier bottling activity had already taken place, including Joseph Biedenharn’s work in Mississippi. The 1899 agreement should therefore be understood as a major step in organized expansion, rather than the first time the beverage ever entered a bottle (Giebelhaus, 2017).

The growing system connected a central syrup supplier with independent bottling businesses. Local operators produced finished beverages and distributed them within their territories. This helped a named product reach many communities without requiring every bottle to travel from one central factory.

The economic logic was straightforward. Finished soda contains a large amount of water. Shipping concentrated flavor and completing production closer to customers can reduce the amount of finished liquid that must travel long distances.

A National Brand Still Needed Local Work

The bottle on a store shelf represented several separate activities: obtaining ingredients, preparing the beverage, filling containers, maintaining equipment, moving inventory, and persuading retailers to stock it.

National recognition could encourage a customer to ask for a cola. A local production and delivery system made the sale possible. Brand growth therefore depended on relationships among businesses, rather than on advertising alone.

This helps explain why cola history includes so many local bottling plants and delivery operations. Their buildings, trucks, bottles, and business records document the infrastructure behind a familiar national name.

1898: Brad’s Drink Becomes Pepsi-Cola

Caleb Bradham developed another important cola in New Bern, North Carolina. Beginning in 1893, he served a carbonated beverage known as Brad’s Drink from his pharmacy. On August 28, 1898, it received the name Pepsi-Cola (North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources, 2016).

Pepsi’s origin illustrates how natural the pharmacy was as a setting for this type of business. Bradham had customers, a fountain, and an interest in a drink he believed could offer digestive and other benefits. Those beliefs belong to the period’s promotional and medical culture, rather than serving as evidence of a modern health claim.

The business expanded into bottling, but growth did not make it secure. The North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources identifies sugar-price and supply fluctuations, bottling difficulties, and marketing problems among the pressures that undermined Bradham’s business after World War I (North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources, 2016).

The surviving brand and the original founder’s company were not identical things. A recipe, trademark, and customer following could continue after ownership changed. Pepsi’s eventual importance should not obscure the instability of its early commercial history.

Cola Was Becoming a Competitive Category

By the 1890s, Coca-Cola’s success had attracted numerous competing drinks. The National Library of Medicine identifies examples with names such as Koke, Cafe-Cola, and Kos-Kola (National Library of Medicine, n.d.).

These names show how manufacturers tried to communicate familiarity. A customer encountering a new product could recognize an association with a type of beverage already gaining attention.

For an established brand, however, similarity could create a problem. The same resemblance that helped a newcomer enter a market could make it harder to preserve a distinct identity. Flavor competition and trademark protection developed together.

This was also the point at which cola became larger than any one recipe. Customers could recognize a general family of drinks while preferring a particular version. That distinction made room for national competitors, regional brands, and later private-label and craft products.

The history of cola is consequently a history of differentiation within similarity. Producers wanted a drink familiar enough to be understood and distinctive enough to be chosen.

Royal Crown and the Importance of Smaller Competitors

Royal Crown’s history began with Claud Hatcher’s line of bottled beverages in Columbus, Georgia, in 1905. His business developed through names including Union Bottling Works, Chero-Cola, and Nehi. Royal Crown Cola appeared in 1934 as the company worked to strengthen its product line during the Great Depression (Bowers, 2026).

The shifting names are a reminder that a modern brand can represent several earlier businesses and products. It would be misleading to describe the entire Royal Crown story as though its later cola had existed unchanged since 1905.

The company’s experience also shows that smaller competitors contributed to the category’s development. Royal Crown participated in packaging and diet-cola innovation, while maintaining a strong regional identity. Its place in Southern popular culture became part of its appeal (Bowers, 2026).

Columbus State University preserves company records, marketing material, artwork, and other evidence from the business. Those archives extend the history beyond a simple contest between Coke and Pepsi and document the work behind a wider range of beverages (Columbus State University Archives and Special Collections, n.d.).

The Contour Bottle Made Packaging Part of the Brand

In 1915, Coca-Cola sought a bottle that customers could distinguish from competing containers by sight and touch. The Root Glass Company of Terre Haute, Indiana, produced the winning design. Its design patent was dated November 16, 1915, and a modified commercial bottle was adopted in 1916 (Kratz, 2015).

The National Archives explains a surprising detail: the bottle’s inspiration came from the shape of a cacao pod. Cacao, the source of chocolate, is different from both coca and kola. The prototype also required practical changes because its proportions made it unstable.

The resulting container gave the brand an identity that did not depend entirely on a printed label. Shape became part of recognition. The bottle’s appearance eventually received trademark protection in 1961 (Kratz, 2015).

This was more than decoration. A distinctive package could help a customer identify the intended product among similar drinks. It also gave advertisements a physical form that could be repeated across signs and images.

The bottle demonstrates how engineering and marketing could solve the same business problem. It had to function as a container while communicating ownership and identity.

Caffeine Became a Federal Court Issue

Cola’s early history also intersected with federal food regulation. In United States v. Coca Cola Co. (1916), the Supreme Court considered a case brought under the Food and Drugs Act of 1906.

One central question concerned caffeine and the legal meaning of an added ingredient. Coca-Cola’s position could not prevail simply because caffeine was part of the company’s established formula. The Court rejected the idea that a proprietary formula automatically placed its ingredients beyond the statute’s adulteration provisions. It reversed the lower court’s judgment and sent the case back for further proceedings (United States v. Coca Cola Co., 1916).

The ruling should not be summarized as a general declaration that caffeine was either harmless or poisonous. It addressed how the law applied and what issues required consideration.

For cola history, the case marks a shift in the terms of public scrutiny. A familiar brand and a long-used recipe did not end questions about ingredients. Manufacturers increasingly operated in a setting where food composition and labeling could become matters of federal investigation and litigation.

From Supposed Remedy to Everyday Refreshment

Cola’s commercial identity gradually moved away from its pharmacy origins. A useful comparison is the difference between early tonic promotions and later advertisements built around ordinary leisure.

The Smithsonian preserves a Pepsi advertisement from around 1959 showing people socializing at a beach. The image places the drink among recreation, conversation, and relaxation rather than presenting it as a treatment for an ailment (National Museum of American History, n.d.-a).

The change in setting reflects a larger change in what the customer was being asked to buy. A tonic promotion emphasizes an expected bodily effect. A leisure advertisement offers participation in a pleasant moment or a recognizable social world.

That shift made cola suitable for more occasions. A product introduced through a pharmacist could be marketed around friendship, meals, travel, or time away from work. Its identity became connected to how people lived and how they wished to see themselves.

The older medicinal background remained part of the origin story, but refreshment and brand preference became stronger foundations for everyday consumption.

Black Sales and Marketing Pioneers Changed Cola Advertising

Edward Boyd and His Colleagues

Cola advertising also reflected the racial exclusions of American business. Edward F. Boyd and other Black professionals working for Pepsi challenged those exclusions through sales and marketing efforts directed toward Black consumers.

Knowledge at Wharton describes the work of a small team operating during the 1940s and early 1950s. Their experiences included the barriers of segregation and the difficulty of securing recognition within corporate America (Knowledge at Wharton Staff, 2007).

Their significance extended beyond selling soda. Employing Black professionals in visible commercial roles and addressing Black customers as an important market challenged assumptions about who belonged in national advertising.

The work also required personal contact with communities and businesses. A campaign was not simply an image placed in a magazine. It depended on sales representatives who understood their audiences and could build relationships under discriminatory conditions (Knowledge at Wharton Staff, 2007).

Representation Became a Business Decision

Hagley Museum and Library’s account of Pepsi’s Black consumer marketing documents advertisements featuring Black professionals and prominent public figures. Its preserved 1977 marketing handbook also shows how later campaigns coordinated newspaper advertising, promotions, radio, and community programs (Harris, 2026).

These records make two parts of the history visible at once. Companies sought additional sales, and the people designing and delivering those campaigns influenced how Black life appeared in commercial media.

The progress was uneven. Internal resistance and changing leadership could interrupt an initiative. A successful campaign did not remove the racial barriers faced by its employees or customers.

For that reason, cola advertising should be read as evidence of both commercial ambition and the limits of inclusion. The images on the page were shaped by decisions about whose lives a national brand was willing to recognize.

World War II Helped Expand Cola’s Reach

World War II strengthened Coca-Cola’s association with American service members and helped expand its international production infrastructure. The company’s wartime commitment to supply service personnel became connected to a wider overseas bottling presence (Giebelhaus, 2017).

Yet wartime access was not uniform. A photograph preserved by the National WWII Museum shows Corporal Hiram Boone holding a Coca-Cola bottle in 1945. The note on the photograph explains that his wife had shipped him two bottles. One broke, and the surviving bottle was warm (The National WWII Museum, n.d.).

The detail is more revealing than a general claim that cola followed every soldier everywhere. It shows a familiar commercial product becoming a personal connection between a service member and home. It also records the practical limitations of shipping fragile containers over long distances.

War helped create markets and infrastructure, but it also gave cola emotional associations that did not come directly from a recipe. A bottle could represent familiarity in an unfamiliar place. That meaning helped link an ordinary consumer product to American life abroad.

Cola Entered the Cold War’s Public Stage

The international meaning of cola became especially visible at the American National Exhibition in Moscow in 1959. Library of Congress photographs associated with the event show Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev tasting Pepsi (Fusco, 1959).

The episode placed a commercial beverage within an encounter between rival political and economic systems. An American soft drink could function as a demonstration of consumer culture as well as a sample offered to a visitor.

The photograph does not establish that one taste changed Soviet policy or immediately created a broad market. Its historical value is more specific: cola had become recognizable enough to appear in a carefully watched international exchange.

The same product could now carry different meanings in different settings. At home, it might be an everyday purchase. At an overseas exhibition, it could stand for American manufacturing, advertising, abundance, or influence.

Cola’s global history therefore includes symbolic circulation as well as commercial circulation. Images of people drinking it sometimes traveled farther than the bottles themselves.

Cans and Plastic Bottles Changed Where Cola Was Consumed

The Move Into Metal Cans

Glass remained an important part of cola’s identity, but metal cans provided another way to package and sell it. The Society for Historical Archaeology’s packaging chronology records Coca-Cola and Pepsi using cans by 1959 and the introduction of drawn-and-ironed aluminum can technology in 1963 (Society for Historical Archaeology, n.d.).

A Smithsonian collection record identifies an early Coca-Cola aluminum can and dates that brand’s adoption of aluminum in place of steel to 1967 (National Museum of American History, n.d.-b).

These are different milestones. The first use of a can by a brand, the development of a manufacturing method, and the transition to a particular metal did not necessarily happen together.

For consumers, a can changed handling and storage. For producers, it required a different packaging system. For the brand, its printable surface provided another format for color, lettering, and promotional design.

The Plastic Soda Bottle

Nathaniel Wyeth’s work on a pressure-resistant plastic bottle supplied another important development. The Lemelson-MIT Program describes his experiments beginning in 1967 and the process he patented in 1973. Polyethylene terephthalate, better known as PET, became the material used in the resulting soda bottle (Lemelson-MIT Program, n.d.).

The challenge was technical. Carbonated beverages could deform unsuitable plastic containers. A practical bottle had to withstand internal pressure while remaining useful for filling, shipping, display, and pouring.

PET provided a lightweight, transparent package with a different set of possibilities from a glass bottle or metal can. A screw closure also allowed consumers to close a bottle again between servings, although opening and resealing does not prevent all carbonation loss.

Taken together, these packaging changes expanded the ways cola could be sold. The fountain glass, distinctive returnable bottle, single-serving can, and larger plastic bottle offered different relationships among portion, portability, storage, and occasion.

Diet Cola Created a New Branch of the Category

The development of diet cola separated a familiar beverage identity from its traditional reliance on caloric sugar. Royal Crown was an important participant in that change through Diet Rite, one of the innovations documented in its historical records (Bowers, 2026; Columbus State University Archives and Special Collections, n.d.).

The Smithsonian dates the introduction of Tab to 1963 and Diet Coke to 1982. It also records the use of aspartame in Diet Coke beginning in 1983, initially in combination with saccharin (National Museum of American History, n.d.-c).

The sequence shows why diet cola should not be treated as one invention with one unchanging formula. Brands entered at different times, used different names, and changed their sweetener systems.

Sweetness Was Part of the Recipe’s Structure

Removing sugar is not equivalent to removing an incidental ingredient. Sugar contributes sweetness and affects the experience of the finished beverage. Replacing it requires a manufacturer to consider how the substitute works with acidity and flavor.

Diet versions also created a branding question. A producer could introduce a separate name, as with Tab, or extend a familiar name, as with Diet Coke. Each approach asked customers to understand the relationship between the established product and a different formulation.

The category now contained products connected by flavor expectations and brand identity, even when their ingredient systems differed substantially.

Changing Sweeteners Changed the Economics of Cola

Cola’s sweetener history also includes the growth of high-fructose corn syrup in the United States. A USDA Economic Research Service analysis describes corn sweeteners replacing refined cane and beet sugars across much of the period from 1970 to 2005. Lower cost and the ease of mixing a liquid sweetener helped explain the substitution (Wells & Buzby, 2008).

This was part of a wider food-manufacturing change, rather than an event limited to one cola brand. It connected beverage production to agricultural processing, ingredient prices, and factory operations.

The history also explains why a brand name does not guarantee an identical ingredient list across every country or period. Manufacturers can change inputs while retaining a product’s commercial identity. To establish what is in a particular bottle, the relevant evidence is its own label and market-specific formulation.

A sugar-sweetened version, a corn-syrup-sweetened version, and a low-calorie version represent different production choices. Their historical significance comes from how those choices affected cost, formulation, marketing, and consumer preference. Describing that history does not require assuming that one sweetener automatically makes a drink nutritionally superior.

The Cola Wars Made Preference a Public Contest

Competition between Coca-Cola and Pepsi became known as the cola wars. The phrase captures the intensity of their efforts to win customers through product positioning, advertising, packaging, and comparisons of taste.

The Pepsi Challenge

The Pepsi Challenge, which began in 1975, used blind comparisons of Pepsi and its main competitor. The University of Florida later incorporated the format into a food science class exercise: in 2008, more than 700 students participated in a tasting organized around the challenge (Erwin, 2026).

The format made a complicated commercial rivalry easy to demonstrate. Two unidentified samples appeared to offer an immediate answer to the question of which drink a person preferred. It also gave taste comparison a public role in brand competition.

The result of any tasting still depends on what was tested and how. An individual response describes that participant’s choice under those conditions. It does not automatically establish a universal ranking or predict every later purchasing decision. That distinction became especially important when manufacturers tried to translate research results into changes to familiar products.

Why Labels and Expectations Matter

The rivalry built on an unusual combination of similarity and loyalty. Both products belonged to a familiar category, yet consumers could treat the choice between them as a statement of preference or identity.

Taste comparisons made that tension visible. Removing the label tests one kind of response. Showing the label tests a situation closer to the branded purchase people ordinarily make. Neither setup asks exactly the same question as deciding what to order with a meal or what to buy for a household.

Later research helps clarify the distinction. In a 2004 study, Samuel McClure and colleagues compared anonymous and brand-cued presentations of Coke and Pepsi. Brand information influenced expressed preferences and measured brain responses under the experimental conditions (McClure et al., 2004).

The study does not show that flavor is irrelevant or that every consumer responds identically. It demonstrates that product knowledge can become part of the experience. That helps explain why a change in recipe can provoke a reaction that a blind taste test does not predict.

1985: New Coke Tested the Limits of Changing a Familiar Product

On April 23, 1985, Coca-Cola introduced a reformulated drink intended to replace its established cola. The Henry Ford’s account describes favorable blind taste-test results for the new formulation and the company’s expectation that it would compete effectively with Pepsi (Braden, 2015).

The response after launch was different. Customers objected to losing the familiar version. In July, the company announced the return of the earlier formula under the Coca-Cola Classic name.

One detail often gets lost in the retelling: the return of the original did not immediately end the new formula. New Coke continued alongside Classic, later becoming Coke II, before eventually disappearing. The brief period in 1985 concerned its role as the replacement for the original, rather than its entire commercial lifetime (Braden, 2015).

Why a Better Test Result Was Not Enough

The episode exposed a difference between evaluating a sample and accepting the removal of a familiar product. A participant can prefer a taste in a test without wanting a long-established beverage to disappear.

Seen alongside later research on brand knowledge, New Coke illustrates how recipes, expectations, and remembered experience can interact. Its lesson is specific: a company changing a familiar product must understand the decision consumers believe they are being asked to make.

Craft Cola Keeps the Category Open to Different Interpretations

Cola’s history did not end with the largest national brands. Smaller producers continue to make versions built around their own ingredient choices and flavor emphasis.

Sprecher’s Puma Kola offers one contemporary example. Sprecher describes it as a fire-brewed cola made in Milwaukee with raw honey, kola extract, vanilla, and cinnamon. Its product description connects the familiar cola category with specific ingredients and a kettle-based production method (Sprecher Brewing Company, n.d.).

The example is useful historically because it makes some of cola’s building blocks visible again. A customer can encounter kola as an identified extract, rather than only as a word inherited through a category name.

A craft cola does not recreate every feature of a nineteenth-century pharmacy drink. Contemporary production, ingredient standards, packaging, and consumer expectations belong to a different setting. The connection is one of continued experimentation within a recognizable family of beverages.

That experimentation also shows why cola should not be defined by the formula of a single brand. Producers can emphasize different ingredients while customers still understand the result as cola.

A Timeline of Major Developments in Cola History

The dates below mark selected developments discussed in the article. They describe particular products, patents, or business events rather than a single uninterrupted sequence of invention.

Date or period

Development

Historical importance

At least the eleventh century

Kola has a documented place in West African culture and trade.

The plant’s history predates manufactured cola by centuries.

1767–1773

Priestley experiments with carbon dioxide and water in Leeds.

Artificial carbonation supplies a foundation for later sodas.

May 8, 1886

Coca-Cola is first served at Jacobs’ Pharmacy in Atlanta.

A pharmacy beverage becomes the basis of an influential brand.

August 28, 1898

Brad’s Drink receives the Pepsi-Cola name.

Another pharmacy cola develops a lasting commercial identity.

1899

A major Coca-Cola bottling agreement is established.

Local production and distribution support wider expansion.

1915–1916

The contour bottle is patented, then adopted commercially.

Package shape becomes part of brand recognition.

1934

Royal Crown Cola is introduced.

A major regional competitor strengthens the category.

1940s–1950s

Black Pepsi sales and marketing professionals challenge exclusion.

Cola promotion becomes part of a broader history of representation.

1959

Khrushchev is photographed tasting Pepsi at the Moscow exhibition.

Cola appears on a highly visible Cold War stage.

1963

Tab is introduced.

Diet cola expands the choices offered by a major producer.

1973

Wyeth patents his plastic soda-bottle process.

PET packaging creates new possibilities for bottled soda.

1975

The Pepsi Challenge begins.

Blind taste comparison becomes a prominent part of cola competition.

1982

Diet Coke is introduced.

A major cola name expands into the diet category.

April–July 1985

New Coke replaces the original, followed by the return of Coca-Cola Classic.

Consumer response demonstrates the importance of established expectations.

 

What Cola’s History Reveals

Cola became a global beverage through the interaction of several developments. Knowledge about kola and coca supplied ingredients and commercial ideas. Carbonation turned flavored mixtures into sparkling drinks. Pharmacies supplied an early marketplace. Bottling systems and new containers widened access. Advertising helped people attach meaning to a name, package, and taste.

The resulting history belongs to more than inventors and company founders. It includes African cultivators and communities, people who carried plant knowledge across the Atlantic, bottling workers, packaging engineers, sales representatives, advertising professionals, and customers whose preferences influenced what companies made.

The drink also changed as it spread. A pharmacy tonic, a bottled refreshment, a wartime reminder of home, a diet product, and a craft cola can all occupy places in the same history without being the same formulation or serving the same purpose.

That is what makes cola’s story distinctive. A product that appears simple in a glass developed through centuries of cultural exchange and more than a century of manufacturing, competition, and changing consumer expectations.

References

Bowers, P. (2026, September 23). Royal Crown Cola Company. New Georgia Encyclopedia.

https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/business-economy/royal-crown-cola-company/

Braden, D. R. (2015, April 23). “New Coke”: Success or failure? The Henry Ford.

https://www.thehenryford.org/collections/explore/articles/new-coke

Columbus State University Archives and Special Collections. (n.d.). Royal Crown Cola collection.

https://archivesspace.columbusstate.edu/repositories/2/resources/127

Erwin, J. (2026, February 3). Five things you didn’t know about the University of Florida’s FSHN Department. University of Florida, IFAS.

https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/fshndept/2026/02/02/five-things-you-didnt-know-about-the-uf-fshn-department/

Fusco, P. (1959). Nixon and Khrushchev [Photographs]. Library of Congress.

https://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2016714732/

Giebelhaus, A. W. (2017, June 6). Coca-Cola Company. New Georgia Encyclopedia.

https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/business-economy/coca-cola-company/

Harris, S. (2026, April 21). Pepsi-Cola and the Black Community Marketing Handbook. Hagley Museum and Library.

https://www.hagley.org/research/Pepsi-Cola-Company-1977-Black-Community-Marketing-Handbook

Kaplish, L. (2025, January 30). Cola’s complicated roots. Wellcome Collection.

https://wellcomecollection.org/stories/colas-complicated-roots

Knowledge at Wharton Staff. (2007, February 28). How corporate America came to recognize diversity, one Pepsi at a time. Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.

https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/how-corporate-america-came-to-recognize-diversity-one-pepsi-at-a-time/

Kratz, J. (2015, June 8). The Coca-Cola bottle: Celebrating 100 years of an American icon. National Archives.

https://prologue.blogs.archives.gov/2015/06/08/the-coca-cola-bottle-celebrating-100-years-of-an-american-icon/

Lemelson-MIT Program. (n.d.). Nathaniel Wyeth: The plastic soda bottle. Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

https://lemelson.mit.edu/resources/nathaniel-wyeth

Library of Congress. (n.d.-a). Today in history: May 8.

https://www.loc.gov/item/today-in-history/may-08/

Library of Congress. (n.d.-b). World’s first Coca-Cola was served.

https://guides.loc.gov/this-month-in-business-history/may/first-coca-cola-served

McClure, S. M., Li, J., Tomlin, D., Cypert, K. S., Montague, L. M., & Montague, P. R. (2004). Neural correlates of behavioral preference for culturally familiar drinks. Neuron, 44(2), 379–387.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuron.2004.09.019

National Library of Medicine. (n.d.). Pick your poison: Exhibition: Cocaine.

https://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/pickyourpoison/exhibition-cocaine.html

National Museum of American History. (n.d.-a). Be sociable, have a Pepsi [Advertisement, ca. 1959]. Smithsonian Institution.

https://americanhistory.si.edu/collections/archival-item/sova-nmah-ac-0092-ref573

National Museum of American History. (n.d.-b). Coca-Cola [Aluminum can]. Smithsonian Institution.

https://americanhistory.si.edu/collections/object/nmah_1379658

National Museum of American History. (n.d.-c). Diet Coke. Smithsonian Institution.

https://americanhistory.si.edu/collections/object/nmah_880981

The National WWII Museum. (n.d.). Cpl. Hiram Boone holding up a Coca-Cola bottle, 1945 [Photograph and collection description].

https://www.ww2online.org/image/cpl-hiram-boone-holding-coca-cola-bottle-1945-1

North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources. (2016, August 28). “Brad’s Drink” becomes Pepsi-Cola, 1898.

https://www.dncr.nc.gov/blog/2016/08/28/brads-drink-becomes-pepsi-cola-1898

Society for Historical Archaeology. (n.d.). Common 20th century artifacts: A guide to dating: Cans, general.

https://sha.org/common-20th-century-artifacts-a-guide-to-dating-cans-general/

Sprague, K. (2017, December 15). The kola nut: West African commodity in the Atlantic world. UCLA International Institute.

https://international.ucla.edu/Institute/article/186740

United States v. Coca Cola Co., 241 U.S. 265 (1916).

https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep241/usrep241265/usrep241265.pdf

University of Leeds. (n.d.). Joseph Priestley. Priestley Centre for Climate Futures.

https://climate.leeds.ac.uk/about/joseph-priestley/

Wellcome Collection. (n.d.). The kola nut cannot be contained: Exhibition text.

https://wellcomecollection.org/guides/exhibitions/the-kola-nut-cannot-be-contained/captions-and-transcripts

Wells, H. F., & Buzby, J. C. (2008, February 1). High-fructose corn syrup usage may be leveling off. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service.

https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber-waves/2008/february/high-fructose-corn-syrup-usage-may-be-leveling-off